Question 1

So does DPC actually replace insurance?

Accepted Answer

No, and it shouldn't. DPC replaces the primary care layer: office visits, chronic disease management, direct access, wholesale labs and imaging. What it doesn't replace is catastrophic coverage, hospitalization, surgery, specialists, ER. Almost every DPC patient pairs the membership with a high-deductible plan and uses the two together. The membership handles 80–90% of what actually happens in a year; the insurance handles the once-in-a-decade event.

Question 2

Is DPC really cheaper for patients, or does it just feel that way?

Accepted Answer

For anyone using primary care more than two or three times a year, it's genuinely cheaper. A $75–$100 membership plus an HDHP typically lands $3,000–$5,000/year under a comparable PPO once you count premiums, copays, deductible burn, and surprise bills. Light utilizers break even. The real savings show up in labs and imaging, DPC negotiates wholesale, so a $400 metabolic panel becomes $12.

Question 3

What about Medicare patients?

Accepted Answer

DPC doesn't bill Medicare, and a physician can either stay a non-participating provider or formally opt out with CMS (two-year commitment). Medicare-eligible patients can still join DPC and pay the membership out of pocket, many do, because a 45-minute visit is worth it. Practices with heavy Medicare demographics plan the opt-out carefully with a healthcare attorney before launch.

Question 4

Are employers actually paying for this?

Accepted Answer

Yes, and it's the fastest-growing channel. Self-funded employers pay $75–$150 per employee per month for DPC access because it materially reduces total spend, fewer ER visits, better chronic disease control, less specialty referral drift. A single mid-size employer contract can anchor a practice's revenue floor. Direct-to-employer sales is now a core part of most mature DPC growth strategies.

Question 5

Are DPC memberships HSA-eligible now?

Accepted Answer

For plan years beginning after December 31, 2025, qualifying DPC arrangements are treated as eligible medical expenses under federal HSA rules, capped at $150/month (individual) or $300/month (family). This is a meaningful shift, it removes a long-standing friction point for HSA-holding patients. Patients should confirm specifics with their HSA administrator and tax advisor, since final IRS guidance may refine the mechanics.

Feature	DPC	Insurance-Based
Monthly cost for primary care	$50-$100/month adult benchmark (AAFP); varies by scope	$200–$400/month premiums + copays
Appointment wait time	Same day or next day	14–21 days average
Visit length	30–60 minutes	7–15 minutes
Doctor access outside visits	Direct text, phone, email	Phone tree, portal messages
Patient panel per physician	400–600 patients	2,000–2,500 patients
Surprise bills	Never	Common
Prior authorizations	None required	Frequently required
Lab & imaging costs	Wholesale (50–90% savings)	Retail + deductible
Administrative overhead	Minimal (no billing staff)	25–40% of revenue
HSA compatible	Qualifying arrangements (2026, caps apply)	Yes (HDHP required)

DPC vs insurance-based primary care

Key Differences

Cost Comparison

DPC Patient (Annual)

Insurance Patient (Annual)

Patient Experience

Physician Experience

It's not either/or, it's a layered stack.

DPC owns

Insurance owns

DPC vs Insurance FAQ

Related Resources

Explore a Better Model